Riffing on another idea prompted by Deirdra’s post: What are The Rules? As I said last time, I have no idea about the back story here—if I did, I wouldn’t be posting about it, because then it would be me inserting my opinion about something that’s none of my business. As it is, being ignorant of the details, as usual, I can talk about the ideas prompted by the topic itself. Which is: The Rules.
I know there are rules—there are rules for everything. Some rules are great: rules about commas, for example, help make what you write easily understandable by your reader. You know, the whole “eats, shoots, and leaves” thing. Rules for driving are good also. We love those rules, never mind that approximately 99.9% of the US Driving Population has no clue what “Yield” actually means. They seem to believe that it is a synonym for “slow down just a tad, then speed up reallyreallyreally fast so you can get there first.”
So what are the Rules for the Mixed Media Community? Who knows? It doesn’t matter, because, in practice, you need only one set of rules, and they apply equally to International Finance and dating and attending an art retreat and being part of any community, anywhere:
1. Play nicely. Show up with a good attitude, ready to contribute and learn and find out new stuff. Think about what you have to offer, and think about what you can learn from people who are willing to share what they know. Don’t come in with a chip on your shoulder or some agenda, like proving how groovy you are or how cool and worldly and jaded. Put on your happy face and try to make others feel at ease. Be encouraging, be honest, be open. If this is too tough for you—if you’re by nature an introverted, bitter, suspicious, angry person, then perhaps it’s best if you stay at home.
2. No hitting. Or biting. Don’t do nasty things to others. Don’t sabotage their work, and don’t spread gossip or rumors or bad news. Don’t be the one who’s sitting at home plotting how to get back at the teacher who didn’t give you enough attention in her workshop or the woman sitting next to you who used up all your red yarn. Don’t try to scoop someone by claiming you had the idea first or by going behind their back to suggest you’d be the better person for the gallery show because, well, really, she’s been having a lot of personal drama, and who can be sure she’ll be able to meet the deadline. You know what I’m talking about here.
3. Don’t be greedy. If you’re thinking about money, money, money all the time, and it’s always about marketing and pushing your work and getting people to give you money for your stuff or your time or your techniques, then you don’t really want to be part of a community; you want to have customers. While people in a community may oftentimes support each other financially, that is not their primary purpose. If you’re trying to insinuate yourself into a group with the main purpose of finding ways to get them to pay you for stuff, you’re lying, aren’t you? You don’t want to be part of a group; you want to build a customer base. If it’s all about money for you, it’s never going to be about community.
4. Don’t take stuff that doesn’t belong to you. If artist A gets an article in a magazine about her Braided Tchotchkes, and if everyone is immediately blogging about Braided Tchotchkes and talking about A’s Braided Tchotchke Workshop, and her Etsy shop, once full of Braided Tchotchkes, is suddenly sold out, don’t you DARE suddenly go, “You know, I’ve always had a fondness for Braided Tchotchkes. In fact, I first made Braided Tchotchkes at my great-grandmother’s knee when I was nothing but a wee lass. By golly, I have as much right to make Braided Tchotchkes as A does!” and then you suddenly start cranking out Braided Tchotchkes for your own brand-new (but you really intended to open one YEARS ago; you just never had the time) Etsy shop. You know it: every how-to piece begins with “I’ve loved bird images my whole life. . .” or “I was using Rusted Metal Things in my art in kindergarten. . .” or whatever other disclaimer the artist thinks will cement their right to jump on the Braided Tchotchke band wagon. This is not about art. This is about taking someone else’s idea—their successful idea, because, really: if you come up with something that totally sucks the big winkie, you don’t much have to worry about anyone else stealing the idea and running off with it, do you?—and trying to cash in on it. It’s about money, it’s about laziness, it’s about greed. You can make up all the excuses you want and try to justify it any way you want, but you know what it is.
5. Share. This is the flip side. If you’re Artist A, and you make a small fortune on Braided Tchotchkes, and everyone is clamoring to learn to make them, teach a workshop. Go ahead: tell them how. Show them samples and give them the handouts and teach them how to do what you do. Why? Because if you’re making art, if you’re an artist, by the time your Braided Tchotchkes become internationally famous, you’re hot on fire with passion for Waxed Potsherds. You live Waxed Potsherds and dream Waxed Potsherds, and making them is all you want to do. You are so over Braided Tchotchkes [and, honeys, imagine how tired I am of typing “Braided Tchotchkes”] that you keep making them only because people are still mad to death in love with them and you can’t bear to disappoint them. In fact, you’re ready to sell the rights to some company, which will pay you well enough so you won’t starve—and there is nothing wrong with making money with your art--just so you can move on to Waxed Potsherds. Because Real Artists are like that: they don’t have The One Big Idea that they ride for a lifetime. Hell, no. They have an idea and then another one and then three more and then half a dozen and then one that GRABS them, and the question is when to find the time to chase them all down and play with them, not how to hide them away and keep them all secret. We all know artists who won’t share: the ones who have Secret Steps or Mystery Ingredients. The ones who say, “You’ll have to take my class to find that out” when all you asked them was what kind of glue stick they like best. Sure, you don’t give away the store when you’re trying to make a living by teaching workshops, but if someone asks you what kind of wax you’re using, good grief: you TELL them. If you’re doing fabulous stuff, they’ll want to take your class anyway. Chances are they’re paying for the class just to hang around you and watch how you work, not to glean the Secrets of Waxed Potsherds. I feel really strongly about this because I couldn’t do the job I do—writing about artists and their work—if artists didn’t share. If they didn’t freely tell about their work and show it and show how it’s done and share their tips and techniques and shortcuts, I’d be out of a job. Everything I write relies on the willingness of artists to share what they do. Do they all share? No. But I guarantee this: the ones who keep it all to themselves, who refuse to share and expect to be paid for every single little tidbit they toss out to the waiting masses? You don’t hear much from them except in very, very rarefied arenas. The ones who do share? They’re the ones posting how-to’s on their blogs and providing videos and giving instructions. Or the ones who, when you contact them to ask a question, do their best to find the time to answer it. Think Judy Wise, who’s a very successful teacher, indeed. She posts tons of how-to stuff and shows step-by-step stuff (remember her paper bag journal how-to?) and shares her journal online. How can she share so much and still work? If you notice, by the time everyone else is excited about whatever it is Judy is doing, she’s already been captured and captivated by Something Brand New. She’s not afraid you’re going to steal her One Big Idea and run away with it; she’s too busy trying to find time for all the million things she can’t wait to try. That’s what art is about.
And those, my sweets, are The Rules.
Go. Play well with others.









23 comments:
Bravo! Very well stated! I completely agree.
This article is so needed!
I believe one other note could be added. If you've taken a workshop for a specific technique/design, and adapt it to your own use, there is nothing wrong with selling that work. However, there is also an ethical obligation to note in any literature that you were either inspired by or first discovered said technique by fabulous artist XXX. It won't diminish the beauty and/or value of your piece - and it keeps you honest.
The other thing that kind of gnaws at me is when people will commission certain aspects of a piece of work, and not give credit to the artist who contributed. In particular, I'm thinking of people who have their fabric piecework quilted by a professional. But the system works in many different areas.
oh - and your definition of "yield" is certainly my experience with drivers here in CT. They are usually the ones who also take red lights and stop signs as mere suggestions.
Well said!
Excellent posts! Thanks.
Rice said; If you’re thinking about money, money, money all the time, and it’s always about marketing and pushing your work and getting people to give you money for your stuff or your time or your techniques, then you don’t really want to be part of a community; you want to have customers.
Being a successful artist who makes her living at it and who promotes herself, is not all about money and greed. It is about surviving and making a living like anyone else but when an artist does it, it is viewed as not playing well in the sand box [community] with others....anti community. Why is art marketing and promoting oneself viewed by you as greed driven when you write books and magazine articles, use blogging/ web site/Facebook /Twitter/You Tube to promote you and your work, and make your living? Not sure what the difference is between what you do and what the artists do that you describe as only wanting customers. . The community concept is nice, sounds friendly but the reality is an artist who is grinding out a living doesn't have too much free time to play in the sand box [community] with others. She is working to pay her bills,expenses, buy supplies, materials and WORKING a lot, a whole lot. I applaud artists who make a successful living and it takes hard work. Yeah, they will have to hustle but the hustle isn't usually about greed. It is about tenacity, drive, motivation, inspiration, promotion, marketing guts and a burning passion for what they do. Money is the by product but that is another post.
i worked my butt off to promote Living the Creative Life, and i didn't get royalties, didn't get a penny from the sales of the book. it was about getting the word out. i don't get commissions on the articles for the magazines--for all this, i get a flat fee, already paid to me by the time the piece is public. marketing your work is all well and good; everyone has to do it. you just have to realize that marketing is NOT the same as being part of a community. if those two seem the same to you, there's a need for reassessment. right away.
Lovely.
I totally agree with you on all these points. I am just a mom at home makin' stuff. I don't have alot of money and I am half a world away from most folks, so any artist that shares their tips and techniques, does a tutorial, etc, is aces in my book. They will get a big thank you from me and credit if I re-create their technique and share it on my blog, etc.
As for the taking another's ideas..I had that happen to me and it shattered a friendship. I was devastated.
Thanks for posting this.
thank you for highlighting the fact that one may take advantage from either side. a community lives in peace.
Perfectly said, Ricë. You always have just the right words.
Peace & Love,
~Barb~
heh. you sure you weren't doing a mind-meld with me?! can't wait to see the fireworks from #5! ;)
Sad that these rules need to be
put down but there you go. Those who need most to think about them will
probably not even get it.
There are divas, spoilers and parasites in every creative
community. We must suffer them
but not always quietly! Well said and many thanks!
Thanks, I agree!!
I have a friend who now teaches some classes in her hometown, a person who started out making cards by hand.
Back then, I introduced her to a vintage images website, and I think I mentioned saving up to buy some more collage sheets. She said, "well, why can't you just print out what's on your computer screen? It'd be cheaper that way."
Never mind the "Please do not copy" message at the top of every sheet. This person said, "well, who's gonna know?"
I was so shocked that all I could stammer was that it wasn't right. No worries: this person has changed. Besides teaching, she also creates her own designs. And worries about other people profiting from her ideas.
Very, very thought-provoking indeed. Thanks Rice. Recently I went seeking inspiration for a fabric frequent buyers/loyalty card holder to make and sell in a quilters sales room. Really just an adapted credit card wallet minus the zippered coin bit.
I brought a pattern from a very reputable artist, but soon found down the bottom that it said not to be sold. Being the honest person I am, I promptly decided against them. Also a problem was that the instructions were appalling, and they only worked with a lot of tweaking. Cha-Ching $16.95.
So I did a blog trawl, and turned up many, many tutorials on the sort of concept I wanted. 99% of these good people simply said take and make with my blessings. All except one.
Now these were only going to be sold in rural Australia. Not online, not on an Etsy store.
But the further I went into it, the more that I discovered everybody was using the same techniques to make these items. So many had been lifted from one particular tutorial that I was getting an almighty sense of de ja oh not AGAIN!
I ended up taking a little bit of this and a little bit of that and made something that was easy to make and pleasing to the eye. But how can you reinvent such a common article?
I did make some up and I sold some too. A lot I have given away, as I still feel like I've stolen something. Very disquitening. But I do not have the skills to just invent. I regularly seek inspiration from cruising the web looking through magazines or books. I love going to the art galleries, even if I do spend a lot of time going WTF? Or What was THAT all about?!?!?
But on the other hand, how can you copyright a spiral? Or the letter J? Or copyright a blind hemstitch?
Recently my best friend took a class with a local quilter. The class was very basic, and quite good, but the teacher specified that no one was allowed to make a quilt using the technique that was being taught without her express approval. Every.Single.Quilt. If she said no, the quilt could not be sold.
OK.
Except for the fact that the technique was found in abundance all over the internet. It was nothing really new, or that uncommon. But now my friend feels like she cannot accept any payment for making one if requested.
I'm OK with teachers protecting their lesson plans, teaching fees etc. But to announce that at the end of class? And to impose those sorts of restrictions?
I'm sorry for rambling, but this really resonated with me.
Thanks again for the wonderful posts Rice!
Thanks Ricë, great article.
Anne, I can't even think what would happen at the school I teach if I was to say to my students, don't you dare using the technique I taught you without my approuval.. It's crazy. I tell them not to copy other people's work but the basic techniques belong to everyone.
Internet is the best and the worst. And it seems a lot of people seem to want to make money out of the things they make.
Don't get me wrong,I'm happy when I sell my jewelry ( it makes room for the things that are still in my head) but I'm not marketing my stuff. I have an etsy store but I think it was a big mistake and I don't look after it because I'm not bothered. I don't try to get into galleries but some galleries asked me to show my stuff and I like it that way.
And if people ask me how I make some stuff I feel confident enough to share with them because I know they are not me and if they're honest they will make their own thing.
Oh by the way, your studio looks great!
This is obviously a serious issue but girl you made me giggle. I only just found your blog today! Lucky me. I don't do mixed media myself; I'm stuck in watercolor for now. But these rules are kind of universal. So thank you. And thank you also for spelling tchotchkes correctly SO MANY TIMES. well done!
Very well written, thanks!
thank you for that, Inner Toddler: after spelling it the second time, i was like, "why didn't i pick another ^%$# word?"
loved it and linked to it!
Great piece as usual. It never hurts to reminded to play nice. And thanks to Tristan for his comment. In fact, thanks to Tristan for pointing the way to this community. He posted a link on quiltart and I found a wonderful neighborhood that I love to hang out in. And now to establish a google account so I don't have to post as anonymous, because though I always sign my posts, I don't want to be confused with other "anonymousi".
Kathy
well said, dahlin, you do have a way with words ;)
You are too much, Voodoo woman. And I mean that in a good way!
Linda
Post a Comment