I’ve been trying to back off the political stuff and focus on creativity, but sometimes I think I’m going to lose my mind reading and listening to all the misinformation, especially the crap published in the local newspaper and the stuff I hear from people I talk to in person, here in Midland, Texas, the Home of Angry Republicans.
I know lots of people who believe health care is just fine the way it is. Hell, I could argue the same thing: we have good insurance, I get good health care, I get to choose my health care providers. Things could continue like they are, and I’d be fine.
But.
Where I differ from many other similarly privileged Americans is that I don’t think everybody else is just like me. I don’t believe that everyone else has the same good life I have. And—and here’s the real core of the matter—I don’t believe that those who do not have the things I have—health care, insurance, good doctors—deserve to suffer.
You know it’s true: a lot of the people who are marching and yelling and protesting and whining about the Downfall of Our Country are pretty much saying, “Screw the rest of you.” They figure if you can’t afford insurance, you don’t deserve health care and some reasonable expectation that you won’t be forced to suffer with some horrid but treatable disease simply because you’re uninsured. It’s easy to like things the way they are if things the way they are are working nicely for you and your family and your friends, all of whom have lives pretty much just like yours.
Unlike those people, I know people whose lives are different from mine. I know people who can’t afford insurance, and I know people who have been denied care. Since I know lots of artists, I know lots of people who are self-employed, and if you know anything about that, you know all about the expense of getting insurance when you’re self-employed. And what about small business owners, like the one I interviewed this morning who’s really, really worried: prices keep going up, and sales just aren’t happening. People depend on your for a salary and for things like insurance, but you can’t provide those things if the money isn’t coming in. Where does that put you, with people depending on you? With YOU depending on nobody but you?
Unlike the people out there foaming at the mouth about how health care reform is The Great Socialist Evil, I know better than to think that people who don’t have health insurance are slackers, lazy bums who don’t bother with insurance because they figure the county hospital will take care of them if they become ill. The people I know most often pay for their health care out of their own pocket, paying more for that care because of the way the insurance companies have rigged things up so that the uninsured help make up for the profits that health care providers might have lost from the insured. And those people forego things like mammograms and prostate screenings and even the most basic dental care not because they don’t care about those things but because they cannot afford them.
I know artists who feel they have to have insurance in case something truly devastating happens, but their only affordable choice is a plan with a really high deductible, meaning that all the minor stuff isn’t covered. It comes down to going in for a mammogram or paying the electric bill.
To all those angry conservatives who are dead set against reform, I say, “Think it can’t happen to you? Think that, because you have insurance and pay your premiums and stay away from The Great Unwashed, you’ll never wish things were different ? Do you think that? “
Then take a look at this. Maybe your insurance premiums aren’t protecting you quite as fully as you think they are:










22 comments:
Oh, Rïce, you've touched the hottest button of all and I can't even be articulate about it. I'm grateful you can. I watch and listen to this every day and I grit my teeth til my jaw is sore. I have sent people home from the hospital before they are ready because their insurance won't pay any more. I have kept people in the hospital longer than necessary because the insurance company refuses to pay for a medication that will send them home and keep their premiums down - staying in the hospital will let the insurer hike their rates. I have sent a middle aged man home following a stroke that left him only unable to speak, when he really needed in-patient rehab, but because he was physically unaffected (he was mobile) his coverage would not allow it. So he went home unable to communicate, his wife had to work to pay bills, and he was left home alone in frustrated silence to go to rehab maybe twice a week. And it's not just the insurance companies. Doctors are paid by the insurance companies and they learn how to work the system to order and justify unnecessary tests. One I know ordered 37 tests on a patient who was nearly ready for discharge. One was a blood level for a drug that not only was the person not on, it's a drug that very few people even prescribe. Unfortunately, though I tried to keep the tests from being done, they were and you know that that person's premiums have skyrocketed.
It's all about money. It's all about a lot of people too worried about "me" instead about "us". And we won't get anywhere that way.
What a horrifying video. And he sleeps well on his 800 thread count sheets.
Kathy/Michigan
I wish I could figure out this blasted google acct.
Times like these, I'm thrilled to be Canadian, despite the evil winters.
I find it pathetic how health care is held up as being the socialist evil. The close mindedness of some people (obviously lots of people) is mind boggling.
As my friend Rachel noted in her blog:
"I’m really sick of health care opponents throwing the word “socialism!” around like it’s a bad thing. I’m also really sick of people cringing from that word in blind fear without at least understanding what that word really means. To put it in simplistic terms, socialism is public property or services paid for by taxes. The post office is socialist. The library is socialist. The police and fire departments are socialist, as are the water and sewage treatment plants. Social security, medicare, highways, prisons and the military, all are socialist. The public schools are socialist. The very foundations of our society, upon which we live and breathe and depend on every day, are socialist!"
This is the post
*Thank you* Rïce and thank *you* to Jazz's comment above by her friend Rachel who actually defines the oh so "scary" word that some are blindly throwing about without actually knowing and understanding what it means.
THANK YOU!
Excellent post! I seriously don't understand the conservative anti-public health care stance AT ALL. I know that many DO have rational reasons for being opposed, but I, in my encounters via the media and in person, have not met a one that presents them. Im starting to think that theres nothing rational about it at all. My sister has a good post also, in which she attacks many of the more common Anti-public HC arguments here
perhaps you and your readers may find them helpful.
Amen! Thank you! I'm so sick of this "Me first, screw you!" attitude so many people have. I'm not even going to get started on this topic. I tend to get very angry at the ignorance and widespread deliberate misinformation. Let me just say that I agree with you 100%.
FYI - http://www.factcheck.org/ is an independent website where you can get the truth. The website is a project of the Annenberg Public Policy Center.
(I just bought your book "Living the Creative Life." Love it!)
I thought one of the most telling stories in recent days was that if healthcare reform goes through, there may not be enough primary care physicians to go around.
I didn't read beyond the headline, because I've reached my weekly wingnut saturation point and I figured the story would have at least one statement that would make me want to puke. However, to myself I thought "Why won't there be enough physicians? Because people who desperately need medical care right now aren't getting it. Many people who need to see a doctor right here and now just can't."
Heaven forbid that everyone in the U.S. should have access to medical care at least as good as I get, or that I should be a little inconvenienced.
Amen sister! I have been sitting through arguments on this topic saying (cause I can't argue point/counterpoint without foaming at the mouth at the absolute idiocy) that I hope health care reform produces the following: 1) health insurance portability, 2) a health care option for self-employed/small business persons that they can afford, and 3) a prohibition against denying coverage/removing coverage for pre-existing conditions and getting sick. So far, no one I've mentioned this to has any issues with those statements. I can point to my parents who've been self-employed or working for small businesses for the last 10 years without insurance. When my parents had a roll-over accident a year ago and my mom had to go in for xrays to the hospital and came out with a $9k bill, the reaction is "that's ridiculous!" and my response is "this is normal and it needs to change!
BTW - got your package in the mail today and love love love it!
Hi Rice
In Australia the privately funded and the publicly funded health care systems sit happily side by side. Medicare, the public system is subsidised by a 1/5% levy on each persons' taxable income. So it is not exactly free.
Everyone pays this - private health insurance or no. Many pharmaceuticals required for chronic illness are also subsidised.
Everyone, regardless of income, or health insurance, has access to free medical care.
There are of course inefficiencies in the public health system. But it is most generally agreed that, in an emergency one wants to end up in a PUBLIC hospital. The are the best equipped.
Doctors get paid very well in both systems. Nurses get paid very badly in both systems.
There is room for improvement.
I can afford private health but I choose to not take it because I am a strong believer in free health (and education) for all. These are the two things that are the greatest equalisers. If one has access to good health care and a good education then after that you can call your success your own, and not the result of a lucky birth.
Great to read your post.
Thank you for speaking up.
Thank you for speaking up.
So why are the wingnut voices the only ones getting media attention? What would happen if all of the rest of us spoke up? LOUD!
Thank you for this post! My husband and I have a small business and we pay a huge amount for insurance. I swear the next time someone suggests that public insurance will lead to socialism, I'm going to suggest we get rid of Medicare, the military, and police and fire departments. (I'm not sure they'd miss the library.)
I have a friend who is a doctor and has a small, cash only family medicine clinic. When she was looking into med school, she was told a number of times that there were too many doctors. But then I guess if you're trying to keep people from getting medical care, you don't need more doctors.
the crazy loons on any issue are always the ones out there yelling and going nuts. i believe it's why things are so weird: their voices are the only ones anyone hears and they think (yikes!) that those voices are speaking for all of us. where, in truth, most of us just don't want to go out into the street and yell at strangers.
watched the movie about the Army of God, the group that promotes murdering abortion providers. holy crap: talk about some loons. of course, many of them have previously served time in prison (some for murder), then heard the voice of god telling them to use any means necessary to stop abortion. they're out in the street yelling = why the sane amongst us are loath to be there, too.
I completely agree and I am so angry and upset at all the lies and stupidity, that I have turned off the TV for a month now.. I used to listen to CNN and MSNBC-- K. Oberman and Rachel Maddow and listen to Air America radio but I just couldn't stand the hypocrisy and outrageous lie any more. I have 3 sons 24, 27 and 30 who work full time jobs and can't afford health insurance so they don't have a doctor or clinic to go to. They go to emergency when they absolutely have to and then they can't afford the outrageous bill they get-- does that make sense?
what a day to bring this up? i just tripped over a manhole cover today just walking down the street and broke my wrist. im sitting here now thinking how my life could change...i feel for those with serious disabilities can certainly pop up any moment. luckily its my non dominant hand.
you neverrrrr know what could happen and when. such lack of compassion in this country:not bleeding hearts bit just genuine civility.
I agree with you 100% about the health care debacle. As a nurse, I have seen how insurance has worked against the people who do have insurance by sending them home too early. You know that the patients will be back in with in a week worse off than they were before and the sad part is that had they been allowed to stay in the hospital long enough the first time, they would have incurred less disability, less expense, and in the long run the insurance company would have been out less money as well. It is a very twisted and broken system. I also do not believe that any insurance company should be allowed to deny a patient a medication that has been prescribed by a doctor because it is not in their formulary. Tough stuff. If the other drugs are not doing the job which they doctor probably already knows because s/he has already tried them, then let the patient have what will work. The denial of services makes me crazy. My sister in law who is a pediatrician in private practice is having to work at the hosptial part-time as a hospitaler because the insurance companies are so slow to pay claims.
Well said. Health insurance can deny treatments and play God, but they are glad to take your money every month. Maybe you can go and speak in front on congress.
SHAME, SHAME, SHAME ON THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA. Greatest country in the world? Not so sure. Remember the video a couple of years ago of the taxi dumping a released person from the hospital, still in their hospital gown, on the city street? It is all about greed and nothing else. The good old USA is always about greed. Remember when Michael Douglas had that line in the movie, Greed Is Good....seems that is the mantra of health care.
yes i hear ya...you see many folks are concerned about the right to life until you cost them to much to live....
thank you for this. thank you for saying what i can't say for lack of composure when i think of this topic.
i am counting down the days till the midterm election. In the days and weeks prior to that election, I plan to make it my personal mission to give everything I can to make sure that my congressman is unseated. To me it's very easy to suss out who is working for me and who isn't these days.
pet peeve: headline health 'care' and report health 'coverage'. i hate that. ditto letters to the editor and newscasts.
i want first a health CARE manifesto. then watch the health coverage players scramble to make it happen because the manifesto would make it illegal for coverage to not meet all care issues.
from cradle to grave.
i want to shove the coverage discussion into orifaces .....
i want nothing but care to be discussed. til all people get it. counter stupid people arguements when it flips to none care examples/slams/science fiction. stick with 'we the people', stick with every man/woman/child. stick with you/your mamma/your children.
when the face of every one you've ever met or seen cannot be erased from your mind, turn to washington and see how fast the manifesto will be written, passed, and made law.
~namaste~
eshep = peshe
sorry
Post a Comment